Skip to Main Content

Research Papers 101: Scholarly conversation + Making sense of scholarly sources

Scholarly conversation + Making sense of scholarly sources

Entering into the Scholarly Conversation

Research is a conversation where many diverse people (scholars, citizens, activists, companies, governments, and others) are discussing your topic. You can find these conversations in academic papers, as well as in other formats like conferences, government white papers, blogs, social media, etc. As a researcher, your job is to listen in on these conversations, understand what's being said, and figure out what it all means. Once you understand what's going on, you can add your own ideas to the discussion.

"Network Tree Diagram," by mat8913 (Mat8913 (talk)), CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Keystone Texts

In scholarly conversations, you'll find both big, widely-discussed topics and smaller, more niche ones. The main discussions usually revolve around keystone texts—articles or books that are cited a lot because they offer valuable, unique, or interesting insights that other scholars find useful. You can discover these key texts by searching Google Scholar using general terms related to your topic.
Cover ArtLove and Death in the American Novel by Leslie Fiedler
Call Number: PS374.L6 .F5 1997
ISBN: 9781564781635
Publication Date: 1998-01-01

Leslie Fiedler's Love and Death in the American Novel has clearly been an influential text in American literary criticism, having been cited over four thousand times.

But some of the books which cite Fiedler are even more influential in their fields:

Cover ArtLove and Death in the American Novel by Leslie Fiedler
Call Number: PS374.L6 .F5 1997
ISBN: 9781564781635
Publication Date: 1998-01-01